Loading promotion info...
The Love I Stopped Waiting For
My girlfriend’s male assistant posted a story on Snapchat. The caption read, “I said rainy days were so boring, so she booked a flight.” The photo showed my girlfriend smiling as she put food on his plate. It reminded me of a few things. Last winter, I had a fever of 102.6. I asked if she could come over. She said it was too far and we’d talk tomorrow. Last month, I told her I wanted to see the ocean. She said to wait until Thanksgiving. She promised she’d come with me then. Thanksgiving arrived. She said work was too busy and told me to go ahead. I booked my own ticket, planned my own itinerary, waited in line alone, and told the server at the noodle shop, “Just one.” Him? All he said was, “Rainy days are so boring.” And she booked a flight, opened a bottle of wine, and photographed the sunset through floor-to-ceiling windows. It wasn’t that she didn’t have time. I just wasn’t worth making time for. On the train, she texted, “Where are you? I’ll come find you tomorrow.” I replied: Don’t bother. She said: What’s that supposed to mean? Stop being dramatic. I stared at those last four words for a long time, then smiled. Then I pressed and held the conversation and deleted it. Two years together. For the first time, my phone felt light. “You’re back sooner than I expected.” My girlfriend, Claire Bennett, sat on the couch. She wore lounge clothes, her hair still damp, as if she’d just showered. As if nothing had happened. I stood by the front door with my suitcase, my shoes still on. “You’ve got your suitcase out? Where are you going?” “I’m moving out.” She shifted, making room beside her. “Sit down. Let’s talk.” “There’s nothing to talk about.” I walked past her into the bedroom, opened the closet, and started throwing clothes into my suitcase. She followed and leaned against the doorframe, arms folded. “Is this about Ryan Cole’s Snapchat story?” I ignored her. “Evan, you deleted our chat, ignored my calls, and came rushing back to pack. Is this how you think two adults should solve a problem?” T-shirts. Hoodies. The charcoal cardigan I’d worn for two winters. I folded them and stacked them in the suitcase. She stepped closer. “You won’t even have one conversation with me before jumping to conclusions?” “What’s there to discuss?” “Then let me explain.” Her voice softened, as if she were soothing a child throwing a tantrum. “It was raining that day. I was in his city on business, and a few coworkers had dinner together. He exaggerated things in his caption. If you don’t believe me, I can send you the group photo from that night.” My hands paused for a second. “You can call our team lead and check,” she added. I said nothing. I opened her side of the closet to see if any of my things had ended up there. The third hanger on the right was empty. I stared at the gap. Last year, I’d given her an indigo hiking jacket for her birthday. She tried it on, said it was too big, and hung it there. It had stayed there ever since. I saw it every time I opened the closet. Now it was gone. “Where’s your blue hiking jacket?” Her expression didn’t change, but her eyes flicked toward the closet for less than a third of a second. “Which one?” “The one I gave you. The one you said was too big to wear.” “I probably left it at work.” “If you never wear it, why would you take it to work?” She smiled, with just a hint of exasperation. “Evan, see? This is exactly what I mean. One piece of clothing isn’t where it used to be, and you decide I gave it to someone else. You’re going to drive yourself crazy.” I stared at the empty hanger and remembered a story Ryan had posted last month. A selfie at a café. The background was blurry, but the jacket draped over his chair was indigo, with a line of darker contrast stitching along the collar. Exactly like this one. I didn’t say it. Even if I did, she’d have ten thousand explanations ready. She always did. I zipped up the suitcase and glanced around the bedroom. Two of my books were still on the nightstand. I reached over and took them. “That’s all you’re taking?” She stood in the doorway, not quite blocking it. She turned sideways, leaving just enough room for me to hesitate. “What about the things in the living room?” I’d picked the curtains. I’d bought the vase on the coffee table. More than half the books on the shelf were mine. But those things belonged to “our home,” not to “me.” After two years, I’d filled this place with so much. Yet everything that was truly mine fit in half a suitcase. “I don’t want them.” She took half a step forward. “Evan, take a couple of days to calm down. Once you do, you’ll realize how ridiculous you’re being.” I walked around her and opened the door. “Don’t regret it once you leave,” she said behind me. I wheeled my suitcase into the elevator. It wasn’t heavy. Half a case of clothes. Two books. My phone vibrated. Jake Morgan. “You out?” “Yeah.” “Was she home?” “Yeah.” “What did she say?” I thought for a moment. “That I’d regret it.” Three seconds of silence. Then Jake said, “Come over. The hot pot’s boiling. We’re waiting for you to cook the meat.”“Ever consider that she’s so calm because she’s sure you’ll go back?” Jake dropped a slice of tripe into the broth and pulled it out eight seconds later, as precise as a surgeon. I said nothing. “You deleted the chat and moved your stuff out, and she didn’t even follow you.” He dipped the tripe in sauce and handed it to me. “Does that sound like someone who’s afraid of losing you?” “Maybe she thought chasing me wouldn’t help.” “No. She thought she didn’t need to. After your old fights, what was the longest you stayed away?” I thought about it. “Three days. Three at most.” “She’s waiting out your three days,” Jake said. The broth bubbled, and steam fogged my glasses. I took them off to wipe them, unable to make out his expression. My phone lit up. A message from Claire: I’ve thought about it. You’re right. I haven’t given you enough attention lately. Get some rest for a few days. I’ll pick you up this weekend, and we’ll talk properly. Jake leaned over, read it, and scoffed. “Stage four of the standard routine. Playing humble.” “What do you mean?” “Watch.” He held up four fingers. “Stage one: anger. Stop being dramatic. She’s already used that. Stage two: shifting blame. We were with coworkers. He posted the picture himself. Stage three: threats. Don’t regret it once you leave. Stage four: backing down. I’ve thought about it. You’re right.” He counted them off, then looked at me. “One, two, three, four. Every single one. Even the order’s the same.” “How do you know so much about this?” “Three years in the ER. I’ve seen it too many times. The one who got violent gets detained, comes to their senses, and goes through the same four stages. Some people get forgiven at stage four. Then the whole thing starts over at stage one.” I looked down at the message, started to reply, then set the phone aside. The next day. A mutual friend messaged me. Mark Foster. He was dating one of Claire’s college friends. We’d had dinner together a few times, but we weren’t particularly close. “Evan, I heard you and Claire had a fight. She’s been pretty out of it today, just sitting in her office staring into space. What happened? Want me to get you two together to talk?” I replied, “We broke up.” He sent a string of question marks. “How did it turn into a breakup? Weren’t you going away together for Thanksgiving?” “She didn’t come.” “Didn’t she say she was busy with the project? Their deadline really is brutal. My girlfriend’s been working overtime for days too. Don’t overthink it. This stuff is normal in a relationship.” Overthinking it. I turned my phone facedown. At three that afternoon, Ryan messaged me. We rarely spoke on Snapchat, but we had each other added. “Hey, Evan. I heard there’s been a bit of a misunderstanding between you and Claire. That day really was just a team dinner. I was careless with my caption, and I’m really sorry it gave you the wrong idea. Claire and I are just coworkers. You have nothing to worry about.” I read it twice. Every word was spotless. Every punctuation mark was perfectly placed. An apology without groveling. A denial without sounding defensive. Like a PR statement. I took a screenshot and sent it to Jake. He replied immediately: “If they really were just coworkers, would some guy at your girlfriend’s company rush to explain himself the second you broke up?” I looked at the message again and suddenly noticed a detail. He called her “Claire.” Not “Ms. Bennett.” Not “your girlfriend.” Not even “she.” Just “Claire,” with an easy familiarity. I’d never had to think about how he addressed her before. To me, she was Claire Bennett. How close did you have to be to someone for their name to sound like an endearment? Jake sent another message: “Notice how he says he ‘gave you the wrong idea’? Not ‘what I did was wrong.’ The problem is your interpretation. He’s apologizing while implying you’re imagining things.” I set my phone down. Another message from Mark: “Evan, Claire asked me to tell you she really knows she messed up. She means it this time. Can’t you give her another chance? It’s been two years. Don’t throw it away over one little thing.” One little thing. Not coming when I had a fever was one. Not reading the itinerary was another. Breaking her Thanksgiving promise was another. Separately, each was a “little thing.” But no one wanted to stack them up and see how tall they’d become. I replied, “Thanks, Mark. But no.” “You’re way too stubborn. Claire has so much going for her. You think you’ll find someone better once you walk away?” I stared at that sentence for half a minute. Then I closed the chat. I didn’t delete it. I didn’t reply. Jake called. “Evan, listen to me.” “Yeah.” “No matter who contacts you these next few days, no matter what she says, remember one thing. You had a fever of 102.6, and she didn’t come. That isn’t a little thing. It isn’t a misunderstanding. It isn’t you overthinking. It’s a fact.” “Facts don’t need explaining. Excuses do.”“Hey, Evan. Came alone?” I turned, wineglass in hand. Ryan stood in front of me, smiling brightly and dressed well. Two guys stood beside him. Both worked at his company. I’d met them at last year’s team outing. It was an industry networking dinner. I hadn’t wanted to come, but the hospital needed someone to attend. “Yeah. Alone.” “What a coincidence. Claire’s here too. I think she’s over there.” He tipped his chin to the right, his voice just loud enough for the people nearby to hear. He said her name so easily. Right in front of me. The guy with the buzz cut looked me over, his tone casually curious. “Evan, aren’t you and Claire together? How come we never see you two together anymore?” “We broke up.” “Oh?” He held his surprised expression for a full two seconds, then quickly replaced it with a knowing smile. “That’s a shame.” His gaze slid toward Ryan, the corners of his mouth lifting. Ryan lowered his eyes, like an innocent bystander embarrassed to be dragged into it. The other guy chimed in. “Honestly, I always thought your personalities didn’t really match. You’re quiet, and Claire’s outgoing. Sometimes a big difference doesn’t balance people out. It just drains them.” Drains them. That was how he described being with me. I smiled. “You’ve got a point.” Ryan stepped in at exactly the right moment, his voice gentle. “Don’t take it personally, Evan. They speak before they think. They don’t mean anything by it. Being single is good too. Sometimes it’s easier.” He was wearing a jacket. Indigo. Darker contrast stitching along the collar. I knew that jacket. I’d spent two hours at the mall choosing it for her birthday last year. I remembered the origami display beside the fitting-room mirror. The three people ahead of me at checkout. The dark green ribbon tied around the shopping bag. She’d said it was too big. She wouldn’t wear it. It had hung on the third hanger on the right. Now Ryan was wearing it. The fit she’d complained about looked perfect on him. He noticed me looking. “Nice jacket, right?” He glanced down and touched the cuff, his tone casual. “Bought it a little while ago. I love this color.” “Indigo,” I said. “Yeah. You like it too?” “I used to see one just like it in Claire’s closet. Same collar. Same stitching. Same color.” His smile faltered for a beat. A very brief one. “Really? Guess we bought the same one.” The two guys exchanged a glance. I said nothing more. That was when Claire walked over. She held a glass of wine. When she saw me, her steps slowed for half a beat. Then she resumed her normal pace and stopped beside Ryan. “Evan.” She nodded, polite as if greeting a colleague she barely knew. I gave her an equally polite nod. Ryan casually put an arm around her shoulders. People nearby were watching. I turned to leave. Behind me, the guy with the buzz cut said, not loudly, but loud enough for me to hear, “Some people don’t appreciate what they have until it’s gone. Too late once the other person’s moved on.” Laughter. I walked to a corner of the room and set down my glass. My palms felt cold. My phone vibrated. Claire. “Don’t talk about our private business in public.” I replied, “What did I say?” “What was that about a jacket in my closet? What are you trying to imply?” “Did you give him that jacket?” No reply. A minute later, she sent, “Can you stop doing this? To everyone else, you look like an ex who won’t let go.” An ex who wouldn’t let go. Four days ago, she’d asked me for another chance. Today, I was an ex who wouldn’t let go. I put away my phone and headed for the exit. As I passed a corner in the hallway, I heard Ryan talking to the two guys. They weren’t keeping their voices down. They were laughing. “The way he looked at my jacket was kind of scary.” “Who cares? You’ve broken up, and he’s still hung up on a piece of clothing.” “I think he just can’t accept it. What can you do if he won’t move on?” Ryan’s voice was soft. “I don’t want things to be like this either, but Claire said he’s been emotionally unstable lately. She told me not to provoke him.” Emotionally unstable. She’d told Ryan I was emotionally unstable. I stood around the corner without making a sound. Leaning against the wall, I tightened my grip on my phone, then loosened it. Outside, I ordered an Uber. Once I got in and shut the door, the driver asked where I was going. I gave him Jake’s address. Two intersections later, my phone rang again. Jake. “What happened? You sound off.” “I just ran into them.” “Her and Ryan?” “Yeah.” “He was wearing the jacket I gave her.” Jake was silent for five seconds. “Evan Reed, come straight here. Don’t think about anything else.” I said okay. Lights slipped past the car window. Then Jake added, “You’ve put up with enough tonight. You don’t have to swallow any more.”“Look at this.” Jake handed me his phone. On the screen was a post one of his coworkers had shared. I opened it. Ryan’s account. A beautifully framed photo of the northern lights in Iceland, the sky alternating between deep blue and emerald green. The caption read: Claire said she’d take me to see the real northern lights at least once in this lifetime. She finally kept her promise. It had been posted two months ago. I stared at the date. Two months ago. Two months ago, I’d asked Claire if she had any vacation time this winter. I wanted to see the northern lights. She’d said we’d talk later. Too many projects lately. The northern lights. Two years ago, when we’d just started dating, we lay on the grass in a park, looking at the stars. She said that when we had enough money, she’d take me to Iceland to see the northern lights. I’d saved a picture as my phone wallpaper and kept it for two years. Six months ago, I brought it up. She said to wait. Two months ago, I asked again. She said we’d talk later. She took him. She’d told him, “In this lifetime.” “There’s more.” Jake swiped to the next screenshot. A Christmas morning post from Ryan. A group picture around a dinner table. Behind them were an old mahogany cabinet and paper snowflakes on the windows. The caption read: Christmas Eve dinner with Claire’s family. Her grandma’s pastries are incredible. I recognized the room. Claire had shown me photos of her grandmother’s house. The mahogany cabinet. The pothos on the windowsill. The painting of fish on the wall. Exactly the same. Two days before Christmas, she’d told me her grandmother wasn’t feeling well. Too many people would tire her out. I shouldn’t come. I’d spent two weeks getting ready. Bought tea and vitamins. Learned to make the custard tarts her grandmother might like. Tried on four outfits and asked Claire to help me choose. She told me not to come. Ryan went. He ate her grandmother’s pastries. Jake said nothing. He sat across from me and waited for me to finish looking. I handed back the phone. “When were these?” “The northern lights were two months ago. The dinner picture went up on Christmas morning. You were still dating her.” Jake’s voice was very quiet. “Evan, none of this happened after you broke up. While you were together, everything she promised you and never did—she did it with him.” I sat on his couch, staring at the fruit bowl on the coffee table. Jake said, “Remember what I asked you the other day? When she first mentioned Ryan and called him ‘clingy,’ was she smiling or annoyed? Do you remember your answer?” I did. She’d been smiling. “Smiling,” he repeated. “The first thing she said when she introduced another guy to you was that he was clingy. And she smiled when she said it. That wasn’t a complaint, Evan. She was showing off.” The doorbell rang. Jake got up. Claire stood outside. She must have gotten his address from Mark. “Evan’s here, right?” Jake stayed in the doorway. “Just let me say a few things to him.” She looked exhausted. “Five minutes.” Jake glanced back at me. I got up and went to the door. When Claire saw me, her lips moved. Her expression looked nothing like the composed face I’d known for two years. Her eyes were red. “Evan.” Her voice was hoarse. “I know you’ve seen those things. I know you hate me.” She’d never spoken to me like that. “I arranged the northern lights trip. And the Christmas dinner,” she said. “But it wasn’t what you think. Ryan helped me a lot at work back then. My parents agreed to invite him to dinner. The Iceland trip was an extra activity on a company retreat.” She paused, as if waiting for me to argue. I said nothing. “I know you’re angry.” She took half a step forward and reached for my hand. I stepped back, leaving hers hanging in the air. “I can change. I mean it. Starting right now, I’ll do whatever you want. If you want me to delete Ryan, I will. If you want me to change jobs, I will.” Jake said coldly, “You can delete him right now. Take out your phone and do it in front of Evan.” She froze. “I’m not talking about empty gestures.” She looked past Jake at me. “Evan, we’ve been together for two years. Are you really going to throw all of it away over this?” Two years again. She always used those two years to weigh me down. “I’ll change,” she said, even quieter. “I promise. From today on, you come first in everything. You want to see the ocean? We’ll go tomorrow. You want the northern lights? I’ll book the tickets tonight.” She sounded sincere. Three months ago, a month ago, even a week ago, I might have believed her. I’d become very good at believing her over those two years. But not today. Because while she said, “I promise,” I saw the phone screen light up in her pocket. I couldn’t read the whole caller ID, but I saw one name. Ryan. She didn’t answer. She might not even have noticed. But his name glowed in her pocket for two seconds before going dark. She was telling me she’d change while he was calling her. Suddenly, it all seemed funny. Not funny in a sad way. Truly, absurdly funny. The kind that made me want to laugh out loud. “Claire.” “I’m here.” “Do you want to answer that call in your pocket first?” She startled and looked down at her phone. Her expression changed for an instant. Jake leaned against the doorframe without a word, his mouth set in an icy line. She turned off the screen. “It’s not important. Evan, listen to me.” “No need.” I pulled the door toward me, signaling for her to step back. “Go home.” “What do you want me to do?” “There’s nothing left to do.” I shut the door. Jake looked at me but said nothing. I went back to the couch and sat down. My phone lay on the coffee table, its screen dark and clean. I picked it up, opened my notes, and started typing. The first sentence was: The night my fever reached 102.6, I asked if she could come over. I could hear video game music on her end of the call. Jake glanced over. “What are you writing?” “I don’t know.” I kept typing. “I just wanted to write.”