Chapter 1
When I was ten years old, my younger brother, Edwin Clifford, locked me in my room while I was running a high fever.
By the time our parents found me, the fever had left me permanently blind in my left eye.
From then on, my parents and my older sister, Susan Clifford, never treated Edwin the same way again.
They stopped buying him birthday cakes, skipped all of his parent-teacher conferences, and stopped buying him new clothes for the holidays. Even Kristen Gardner, my childhood friend who used to spoil him rotten, stopped calling him "Eddie."
Instead, they showered me with love and extra care to make it up to me. Mom took me to every medical checkup. Dad drove me to and from school every day, and stood up for me whenever my classmates made fun of me.
Kristen held my hand and kept telling me, "Blake, I'll be your eyes from now on."
I genuinely believed they cared about me β until the day we submitted our college applications.
Edwin broke down in tears, saying he wanted to stay in the city with Susan and Kristen and make a fresh start.
I planned to apply to an out-of-state college on Edwin's behalf and said, "That's a good school. It's the best option he has with his scores."
A heavy silence fell over the dinner table.
Then Mom suddenly burst into tears. "I won't allow it!"
Chapter 1
"For eight years, we never celebrated Eddie's birthday or attended a single parent-teacher conference. We didn't even buy him new clothes for the holidays," Mom said. "Blake, you only lost one eye. Eddie lost eight years of our love."
My sister, Susan Clifford, spoke up in a choked voice. "We've spent eight years making it up to you. Why can't you just leave him alone?"
My childhood friend, Kristen Gardner, lowered her eyes and spoke softly. "He just wants to put all this behind him and start afresh."
The application form in my hands slowly crumpled.
Mom cried as she asked, "Do you want Edwin to carry this guilt for the rest of his life?"
Half my world was already dark. In that moment, the other half went dark, too.
That night, I changed Edwin's college application back to the local college in town, canceled all my plans with Kristen, and decided to attend a university far from home.
From then on, they would never have to pretend they didn't love him in front of me anymore.
After updating Edwin's college choice on Susan's computer, I noticed a folder titled "Eight Years of Making It Up to Eddie".
I stared at the folder name for a long time before clicking it.
The first photo was taken three days after I was hospitalized for my eye injury.
Edwin was wearing a birthday hat, sitting in front of a three-tier cake at a seaside hotel. Mom had her arms around him, her eyes red from crying.
The caption read, "Eddie has been through so much. We have to make sure he gets his birthday celebration."
Dad stood beside them, holding a brand-new camera. Susan had bought him the latest gaming console, while Kristen stood behind him, lighting fireworks.
Everyone in the photo was smiling. I was the only one missing.
That exact same day, I was lying in a hospital bed with my left eye wrapped in thick bandages. I was in too much pain to sleep. I called Mom and asked if she could come stay with me for a bit.
She sounded exhausted over the phone. "The whole family is a mess because of what happened to you. Try to be understanding, okay?"
Back then, I had even felt guilty, thinking I was the one burdening everyone. But I was wrong. They had just been too busy comforting the child they actually cared about.
I kept scrolling.
All that talk about him never getting a birthday? They threw him even more lavish private parties.
The parent-teacher conferences no one supposedly attended? Susan and Kristen had simply taken turns getting time off work to be there.
His supposedly missing holiday clothes had actually been purchased through a separate department store account.
In every photo, Edwin was beaming. My parents and Susan were there, and so was Kristen.
The day I went for a follow-up appointment for my damaged left eye, the doctor recommended a better prosthetic eye shell that would fit more comfortably and cause less irritation to the eye socket.
But Mom said, "It's too expensive. He's blind in that eye anyway. Anything that covers it up is fine."
That same day, she bought Edwin a watch worth 10,000 dollars. In the photo, Edwin was trying it on while Mom straightened his collar. The caption read, "Eddie deserves nothing but the best."
I stared at those words, and my eye suddenly stung. My left eye was completely numb, while my right throbbed with pain.
Kristen had promised to buy me a watch with large numbers. Since I had trouble reading small print, she said she'd help me keep track of the time.
I'd waited three years for that watch, but it never came. Meanwhile, Kristen had commissioned an entire wall of starry lights for Edwin. The caption read, "Eddie is afraid of the dark. He gets scared when he wakes up at night."
I'd been afraid of the dark for eight whole years, too. Ever since the accident, I'd wake up in the night, unable to tell whether the darkness was the room or my eye.
Suddenly, I heard footsteps outside. Susan stormed into the room, frowning. "Blake, what's wrong with you? How dare you snoop through my private files?"
I looked up at her. "Is this really private? Or was this all part of the show you put on for me, and you just forgot to delete the evidence?"
Susan froze. Mom and Dad rushed over, too.
When Mom caught sight of the album, all the color drained from her face, but she quickly recovered and explained, "We were just afraid Edwin wouldn't be able to handle it."
Dad's face fell. "We've spent eight years making it up to you. Don't push your luck."
So wanting them to be honest with me was pushing my luck?
Kristen stood in the doorway. Her eyes fell on my reddened right eye, and her fingers twitched as if she wanted to come over to me.
But Edwin burst into tears and hid behind her. "Is Blake mad at me again?"
Kristen's hand froze in midair before finally settling on Edwin's shoulder. She gently comforted him. "No, he isn't. Don't be scared."
Chapter 2
I looked at Kristen's hand resting on Edwin's shoulder and suddenly felt there was no point in arguing anymore.
I went back to my room and packed my ID, my eye medical records, and everything else I needed into my suitcase.
At that moment, I finally understood. It wasn't that they didn't know how to love; they just never loved me.
The next day, I went to the hospital where I'd first been treated for my left eye eight years ago. I told them I wanted a copy of my old medical records.
The doctor paused when he saw my name on the chart. "Blake Clifford?" Then he looked up at my left eye and asked hesitantly, "Why was the nerve repair surgery canceled?"
My fingers froze. "Surgery?"
The doctor frowned and pulled up my old records. Text scrolled across the computer screen. "Optic nerve not completely damaged. Repair within three months may preserve some light perception. Surgery was strongly recommended as soon as possible."
The surgery cost 60,000 dollars. Dad had already paid the deposit back then.
I looked at the payment receipt, and my heart clenched. I hadn't been completely hopeless from the start. There had actually been a chance for my left eye to regain partial vision.
But the next page was a refund receipt. The name on the signature column was Gary Clifford, my dad. The refund was dated the day before Edwin's piano competition final.
Right under the notes section, it read, "Family has decided to discontinue treatment and requests a full refund."
I took the printouts and left the hospital.
The afternoon sun was blinding outside, making my right eye throb, but I couldn't stop staring at the papers in my hands.
So, they'd had the money for my surgery. They simply hadn't wanted to spend it on saving my sight.
When I got back home, I heard piano music coming from Edwin's room upstairs. His door was slightly ajar, and I stopped outside.
His white grand piano stood in front of the floor-to-ceiling windows, its polished surface gleaming in the sunlight.
I had always thought the piano was a prize. It wasn't.
I caught sight of the brass plaque beside the piano lid. "To our dear Eddie. May you always stand in the spotlight." It was signed by Mom, Dad, Susan, and Kristen. The purchase date was the same day my surgery deposit had been refunded.
I remembered that period of time suddenly. The doctor had told them I needed a quiet place to recover. But Mom brought me home and put me in the smallest bedroom on the first floor.
Every day, I could hear piano music coming from upstairs, over and over again. I'd lie in my room with my hand over my eye, unable to sleep because of the pain.
Mom would come in and say with annoyance, "Eddie is finally willing to play again. Don't ruin it for him."
Now I understood. They'd used the money meant to save my eyesight to buy Edwin that piano. They'd sacrificed my chance to ever see light with my left eye so Edwin could have that piano.
I pushed the door open, and the music stopped abruptly.
Edwin turned around. When he saw the documents in my hand, the color drained from his face.
I placed the refund receipt on top of the piano.
"How does this piano sound?" I asked. "They bought it with the money from my surgery. It'd better sound amazing."
Edwin didn't respond.
Mom hurried in a moment later. When she saw the refund receipt, she said in a soft, coaxing voice, "The doctor couldn't guarantee the surgery would work."
Dad came in frowning. "Don't put it like that. Edwin was in a bad place back then. If he had given up on that competition, it would have crushed him."
Susan gave a cold laugh. "You can still function with one eye, Blake. Eddie couldn't just throw his dream away."
I could still function with one eye.
Hearing those words made it hard to breathe. Apparently, they'd already decided that as long as I could still function, my pain didn't matter.
Since I could still function, I didn't need treatment. Since I could still function, it was fine to let me suffer. And since I could still function, they took away the last chance I had and traded it for Edwin's spotlight.
Kristen stood at the back, her face pale. She stared at the refund receipt for a long time without saying a word.
"Did you know about this, too?" I asked her.
Her eyelashes fluttered, but she didn't deny it.
Something hit me in the chest. It wasn't a hard blow, but it left me feeling completely hollow.
I'd always thought Kristen was different from the rest of them. She remembered how afraid I was of the dark and how much I struggled to see steps. Whenever we were in a crowd, she'd instinctively walk on my left side.
But she knew all along. She knew my left eye might still have been saved, and she knew exactly where that white piano had come from. She'd simply chosen to keep quiet.
Edwin suddenly burst into tears. "I'm sorry, Blake. I really didn't know."
He said he didn't know. But he'd been playing that piano for eight years. All those years, my left eye had throbbed on rainy days and burned under bright lights. I'd also had to endure other people's stares and judgment. Yet not once had he asked how I was doing.
I let out a bitter laugh, and my eyes burned. Tears fell only from my right eye. My left remained dry, an empty ache where hope used to be.
I wiped my tears away and carefully gathered my medical records, including the refund receipt.
I didn't argue with them anymore. I'd realized that you couldn't reason with favoritism. They'd already made their choice long ago, and no matter what I said, I was always in the wrong.
As I walked out of the house, the piano started playing upstairs again, but this time, the music sounded halting and uneven.
I stopped at the front gate and looked back. The white curtains billowed in the breeze, and the room glowed like something out of a fairy tale.
Standing outside, I finally accepted it.
Some places weren't meant to be home. They were just reminders that it was time to walk away.
Chapter 3
I didn't go straight back to school. Instead, I went to the old house where the incident had happened eight years ago.
The place had been abandoned for years. The only person there was an elderly security guard who watched over the property.
When he recognized me, he stared at my left eye for a long time. "You're the Clifford family's older son, aren't you?"
I nodded.
He was quiet for a moment before pulling an old logbook out of a cabinet. He flipped to a page from eight years ago and pointed to an entry.
"Severe storm. Power outage. Unusual noises from the attic, possibly a child crying. Family members arrived at the scene and insisted that the police not be called."
My finger stopped on that line.
The security guard sighed. "I was going to call the police that night, but your father stopped me. He said it was just a fight between siblings and there was no need to involve other people."
My throat tightened. All these years, I thought no one had heard me crying, but someone had. And my parents had stopped them from helping.
Standing near the attic stairs, every last detail of that night came rushing back.
That night, I had a high fever and was so dizzy I could barely think. Edwin tricked me, saying he had lost his favorite model airplane in the attic. I went up to help him look for it, but as soon as I went inside, he locked the door from the outside.
"Kristen's always talking about how great you are. You can just stay in there," he'd said.
Then the storm hit, and the power went out, plunging everything into total darkness. I cried and pounded on the door, screaming for Mom, Dad, Susan, and Kristen. But no one came.
Dizzy from the fever, I lost my balance and fell, hitting my left eye against the sharp corner of a wooden crate. The pain was so intense I couldn't even manage a scream.
Right before I passed out, I heard Edwin crying outside the door. "Mom, Dad... is Blake going to hate me?" he sobbed.
When my parents arrived, the first thing they did was hold him. They comforted Edwin, cleaned up the scene, and agreed on what to say.
By the time I was taken to the hospital, the doctor just shook his head. "If he'd gotten here a few hours earlier, we might have been able to save his vision."
I came back to myself and looked around the attic. I took pictures of the logbook with my phone, then photographed the attic doorframe and the wooden crate.
Just as I walked out of the house, my family and Kristen arrived.
Mom's expression changed the moment she saw the photos on my phone. "Blake, it's been eight years. Why are you still digging up the past?"
Dad's voice was stern. "Eddie was only ten back then."
Susan glared at me. "You're just trying to get back at us."
I turned to Kristen.
She opened her mouth, her voice hoarse. "Blake, Edwin's been having nightmares about it for years."
I looked at her and suddenly found it absurd. "He gets nightmares, so everyone rushes to comfort him. What about the eight years I've spent unable to see out of my left eye? What did those years mean to you?"
Kristen was at a loss for words.
I didn't need to wait for her answer. I already knew.
When Edwin had nightmares, the whole family gathered around to comfort him. When I was left in the dark, I was expected to get used to it on my own.
I uploaded the photos to the cloud.
Mom reached for my phone, trying to snatch it away, but I stepped back. Her hand froze in midair. For the first time, she looked genuinely panicked.
I left and headed to the school's computer lab.
My fingers were still trembling when I sat down in front of a computer. The college application portal was simple and straightforward. There were fields for my name and scores, followed by the final confirmation of my choices.
I looked at the college far from home and clicked Submit. A confirmation message popped up on the screen. I didn't cry.
I just felt strangely light, as if a weight I'd carried for eight years had finally been lifted.
Chapter 4
After changing my first-choice college, I got a call from Mom.
Her voice was unusually gentle. "Blake, come back tonight. We're throwing a send-off party for you and Eddie at a hotel. We've got your ID and all the paperwork ready, too."
I went anyway, but not because I was holding out hope. I needed to get my documents back.
When I arrived at the hotel, everyone was waiting in the lounge. Sitting on the coffee table was a printed document titled "Statement Regarding the Attic Incident Eight Years Ago".
I picked it up and read through it.
According to the statement, I'd been delirious with a high fever and had wandered into the attic on my own. Edwin had just been too young to know how to get help. The whole thing had been an accident.
The last line read, "I, Blake Clifford, have forgiven my younger brother, Edwin Clifford, and ask the school and our family friends to drop the matter."
I read that last line again in disbelief.
Eight years ago, I'd pounded on the attic door until my palms were covered in blood, but no one had opened it.
Now, eight years later, they were finally willing to open that door. Only this time, it was to make me admit I'd gone in there on my own.
Mom pushed a pen toward me. "Belcus University requires applicants to disclose any disciplinary issues. Eddie can't start his freshman year with this hanging over him."
I didn't take the pen.
Dad's expression darkened. "We've already called the college you applied to."
Mom avoided my eyes. "We just explained our side of the story. We told them that you'd always held a grudge against Eddie because you lost your sight.
"We said that the fever had affected your memory, and that you'd deliberately framed Eddie. We also told them you only applied so far away to get back at us."
I stared at her, my breath catching in my throat.
Susan gave a cold laugh. "Without your ID and supporting paperwork, let's see how you plan on enrolling."
Dad rested his hand firmly on top of my ID documents and official records.
They must have taken them from my room when I was out.
"Without these documents, how do you expect to get enrolled?" Dad asked.
So that was why they'd asked me to come back. They hadn't intended to return my documents. They'd brought me here to show me the last path I had left, then break it with their own hands.
Edwin sat beside Mom, his eyes red. "Blake, I just want to put all this behind me and move on."
I turned to Kristen. "Did you know they called the college?"
Her lips moved, but no words came out. After a long silence, she finally spoke in a hoarse voice. "Blake, just sign it. Once Edwin starts college, I'll help you reapply somewhere else."
I let out a hollow laugh. Eight years ago, their priority was comforting Eddie before taking me to the hospital. Eight years later, their priority was protecting Edwin's future before worrying about mine.
Apparently, my eyesight, my reputation, and my college education could all wait.
In the end, I picked up the pen.
Mom visibly relaxed. Edwin lowered his head, his shoulders trembling slightly, as if he'd finally gotten the ending he'd been hoping for.
I signed my name on the statement.
After I finished, Dad pushed my ID documents and a folder toward me. "See? This would've all been avoided if you'd just signed."
Without saying a word, I picked up my things and walked out of the hotel.
That night, I left the city with my suitcase.
I later learned that on Edwin's first day of college, the whole family went with him to Belcus University.
He stood at the entrance in a white shirt, his eyes red. "I wish Blake could be here, too."
Dad scoffed. "Forget about him."
Susan added, "After what Mom and Dad told his college, let's see if he can still get in."
Just then, Mom's phone rang. The caller ID showed Belcus University's admissions office.
She answered with a smile, but a second later, all the color drained from her face.
The voice on the other end was clear. "Mrs. Clifford, we've completed our initial review of Edwin Clifford's application. His admission has been suspended pending a final decision."