My Mafia Fiancé Sent Me to Room 1206. I Changed Grooms

NovelShort new Completed

A week before I was supposed to marry the heir to one of New York’s oldest Mafia families, a stranger asked what I’d do if my best friend had been sleeping with him for years. For three years, I’d run an anonymous advice page under the name Dr. Henson. By day, I saw patients through a clinic, mostly over video. After hours, I answered questions from readers on the page. My fiancé’s father wanted it down before the wedding. He didn’t want reporters digging through my old posts once my name went in the papers. I posted a goodbye and opened the account settings. Just as I was about to hit Deactivate, a message came in from a new follower with a blank profile. Dr. Henson, what if your best friend had been sleeping with your fiancé for years and you found out a week before the wedding? Could you live with that? I should’ve asked who was writing. Instead, I typed the first thing that came to mind. My best friend would never sleep with my fiancé. I almost laughed when I hit Send. Leonora Fox and I had known each other since we were girls, back when our fathers sent us to the far end of the table at Sunday dinner. I knew how she took her coffee after a sleepless night. I knew she’d been pregnant ten times and had never brought a baby home. I’d driven her home from the hospital more than once. She’d never told me the name of the man she kept going back to. Whoever he was, she was still taking his calls. I went back to the settings. My thumb was over the button when my phone buzzed again. This time it was Seth, my fiancé. Babe. The typing bubble disappeared. Then it came back. What if I told you I’ve been sleeping with your best friend?

Chapters (4)

Chapter 1

A week before I was supposed to marry the heir to one of New York’s oldest Mafia families, a stranger asked what I’d do if my best friend had been sleeping with him for years. For three years, I’d run an anonymous advice page under the name Dr. Henson. By day, I saw patients through a clinic, mostly over video. After hours, I answered questions from readers on the page. My fiancé’s father wanted it down before the wedding. He didn’t want reporters digging through my old posts once my name went in the papers. I posted a goodbye and opened the account settings. Just as I was about to hit Deactivate, a message came in from a new follower with a blank profile. Dr. Henson, what if your best friend had been sleeping with your fiancé for years and you found out a week before the wedding? Could you live with that? I should’ve asked who was writing. Instead, I typed the first thing that came to mind. My best friend would never sleep with my fiancé. I almost laughed when I hit Send. Leonora Fox and I had known each other since we were girls, back when our fathers sent us to the far end of the table at Sunday dinner. I knew how she took her coffee after a sleepless night. I knew she’d been pregnant ten times and had never brought a baby home. I’d driven her home from the hospital more than once. She’d never told me the name of the man she kept going back to. Whoever he was, she was still taking his calls. I went back to the settings. My thumb was over the button when my phone buzzed again. This time it was Seth, my fiancé. Babe. The typing bubble disappeared. Then it came back. What if I told you I’ve been sleeping with your best friend? …… Seth sent the address before I could answer. The Marlowe. Room 1206. The Vances owned the Marlowe. Seth’s father kept the top floor for family and for guests who needed privacy. I’d been there often enough to know the doorman by name. I don’t remember how I got downstairs or how I found a cab. I remember giving the driver the hotel name and spending the whole ride waiting for Seth to text again. Come on, babe. I’m kidding. By the time we pulled up, I could almost hear him saying it. The doorman stepped aside without a word. Upstairs, the door to 1206 was ajar. Seth had left it that way for me. I pushed it open. He was in bed with Leonora Fox. She had her cheek against his bare shoulder. When she saw me, she sat up and pulled the sheet to her chest. Seth stayed where he was. He looked more annoyed than surprised. “Jesus, babe. Did I really have to give you a room number before you’d believe me?” My eyes burned. I’d spent the cab ride thinking of all the things I’d say if it turned out to be true. In the room, I could only get one word out. “Why?” “You know me, Clara. I have needs.” He said it as casually as if he were explaining why he’d ordered room service. “Ever since what happened to you, you can barely stand to have me touch you. With Leonora, I don’t have to stop every five seconds to ask if she’s okay.” Leonora looked down at the sheet bunched in her hands. “We don’t even use protection,” he went on. “If she gets pregnant again, she’ll take care of it. She always does.” “Enough.” I crossed the room and slapped him. His head turned with it. For the first time since I’d walked in, he looked surprised. “You’re a goddamn animal, Seth.” I turned to Leonora. She was still holding the sheet against her chest. I’d held her coat and her handbag while she cried in a hospital bathroom. I’d sat beside her afterward, waiting for a man she swore would come this time. “I treated you like family. You were supposed to stand beside me next Saturday. Were you really going to let me walk down that aisle without telling me?” She scrambled off the bed, caught a foot in the sheet, and dropped to her knees in front of me. “Clara, I’m sorry. It was me. I went after him. I knew what I was doing, and I did it anyway.” Her voice cracked. “I’ll go. I won’t see him again.” “She’s staying.” Seth took her by the arm and helped her up. Then he looked at me as though I’d made some unreasonable demand. “She never asked me to break off the engagement. Never asked for a ring or even for me to tell her I cared about her. She was willing to keep quiet so you could have the wedding you wanted. And now you want to run her off?” I hadn’t asked Leonora to go anywhere. I’d barely had time to ask her why. “And when the Hensons found out you weren’t theirs,” he went on, “who stuck around? You remember what people said about you. Leonora was the one who came to your door when everyone else was passing that video around.” He put a hand on her shoulder. She leaned into it. “You’d be dead without us, Clara. We’re getting married in seven days, same as we planned. I told you I’d take care of you. I keep my word.” The tears came before I could turn my face away. I stood there looking at the two people I’d once trusted with things I’d never told anyone else. I was seventeen when the woman I called Mom got sick. She needed blood, and I went to the hospital to see if I could donate. The screening turned up a blood type the family hadn’t expected. The Hensons insisted on a DNA test. When the results came back, I found out I wasn’t their daughter. The men I’d grown up calling my father’s had driven me to school and waited outside my piano lessons. One of them put my suitcase on the front step the night the results came in. By midnight, word was already out. Men who’d spent years keeping their distance from a Henson cornered me in an alley. I’d spent years learning how to talk about what they did to me. Seth had just used it to explain why he’d slept with my best friend. The video first made the rounds on campus during my sophomore year. My roommates stopped talking when I came into the room. One of my professors asked, in front of the class, which last name I wanted him to use. Leonora lived next door. We’d barely spoken since the Hensons threw me out. She knocked the night the video surfaced, brought two coffees, and sat on the floor with me until I was ready to talk. She came back the next day, too. And Seth Vance, my sweetheart since we were kids, came to campus when he heard about the video. He took my hand in front of a crowd outside the lecture hall and said it loud enough for everyone to hear. “Whatever name she goes by, she’s still my fiancée.”

Chapter 2

I’d believed him because he’d been there when it happened. After the assault, Seth took me to the hospital and waited outside the exam room with my coat folded across his knees. At the precinct, he sat beside me while I gave my statement. Every time I had to stop and the detective glanced at the clock, Seth said, “She’ll tell you when she’s ready.” Years later, after the video surfaced, he walked me to class until people stopped gathering outside to stare. On the steps one morning, he squeezed my hand. “Whatever happens, Clara, I’m right here.” I believed him. I believed Leonora, too. There’d been nights when I lay awake thinking that, after everything that had happened, I was lucky to have either of them. Now I stood in Room 1206 counting the times I’d driven Leonora to a clinic. She’d told me about the miscarriages first. Later, when she needed someone to take her home after an abortion, she called me. Every time, I offered to call the man she was seeing. Every time, she said no. Once, I’d come home from her apartment well after midnight and found Seth asleep on my couch. I’d tucked a blanket around him. I barely made it out of the room before I gagged. I took the stairs down and kept walking long after I’d passed the corner where I could’ve caught a cab. By the time I stopped, my face was dry. I dialed a number I’d sworn I would never call. “Mrs. Henson, you asked me to take Alma’s place with the Ashfords. I’ll do it.” There was a small, delighted intake of breath. The woman I’d once called Mom had found her biological daughter. She’d promised Alma to the Ashfords before she realized she could get her into the Vance family instead. She’d asked me to give up Seth and take Alma’s place. “Then I’ll speak to the Vances about Alma,” she said. “I’ll tell the Ashfords you’ve agreed. They’re still expecting a luck bride from our family.” A luck bride. The Ashfords believed bringing a new bride into the house could turn the family’s fortunes. Mrs. Henson had explained the custom the first time she made the offer. Back then, I’d only heard what she wanted me to give up. Now I knew what it would cost me to stay. “I can be in Harbor City by Saturday,” I said. The next morning, I went to the clinic to resign. Closing the advice page was easy. Leaving my patients took more care. I’d brought a list of people who’d need referrals and wanted to go over it with the clinic director before I left New York. The receptionist looked down at her keyboard when I walked in. Farther down the hall, someone shut a door. A colleague stepped out of the staff room with his phone in his hand. Months earlier, I’d reported him for cornering me after work and asking what it would take to get me alone. Now he had a reason to come after me in front of witnesses. “And here I thought you were such a good girl,” he said. He held his phone up to my face. I recognized the brick wall in the first frame. “Seventeen and passing out condoms in an alley,” he said. “You do that for your male patients, too?” I reached for his phone. He jerked it away, grabbed my bag, and upended it. My keys skidded under a chair. A few unopened boxes of condoms fell out beside them. I’d picked them up for the clinic’s patient resource cabinet. He nudged one with his shoe. “How many men have you slept with, Clara? If I’d known you were this easy, I’d have saved myself some trouble.” I could see the alley again. The brick scraping my shoulder. A hand pinning my arm. I’d offered a condom because I was terrified and doing whatever I could to survive. Whoever had cut the video had left out the part where I tried to get away. “What’s the matter?” he said. “After all that time acting like you were too good for me…” I slapped him. He grabbed my hair and threw me down. My cheek struck the corner of a chair, then my knees hit the floor. By the time I could see straight, he had me pinned. “After all those guys,” he said, “what’s one more?” I screamed. My hand caught the leg of the chair beside me. I swung it, felt it hit him, and felt his grip give. Somewhere behind us a door flew open. I got to my feet and ran. Outside, it took me three tries to unlock my phone. Someone had posted the video in the staff group chat from an account with no name or picture. Seth had told me years ago he’d had it taken down. I’d believed him because he was a Vance and because I needed to believe somebody could make it go away. I sent the post to a private investigator who’d helped me trace copies of the video back in college. He called ten minutes later. A former classmate had just sent him the same clip and a screenshot of the message it came in. Leonora Fox’s name was at the top. A sentence from my old roommate came back to me. She sold you out, Clara, and you’re sitting there helping her count the money. I’d stopped speaking to her after that. At the time, it had sounded like one more person taking a shot at the only friend I had left. I texted my old roommate from the sidewalk. What did you mean when you said Leonora sold me out? She answered in under a minute. People were saying she sent the clip around back then. I couldn’t prove it. I did know she’d wanted Seth for years. I looked at the screenshot again. I couldn’t prove she’d sent it the first time, either. But after years of polite hellos, Leonora had chosen the night the video went around to knock on my door with two coffees. I’d spent years telling people she was the only one who came.

Chapter 3

Once I thought about it, I couldn’t remember the last time Seth and I had gone out without Leonora turning up. At the Vances’ supper club, she’d slide into the booth before the waiter brought the wine. Anywhere else, Seth would say she was nearby and ask if I minded. Of course I didn’t. She was my best friend. I went back to the apartment I shared with Seth, my phone still open to the investigator’s screenshot. The doorman at Seth’s building on the Upper East Side took one look at me and reached for the house phone. I waved him off. The brass key Seth had given me still turned in the lock. I shoved the door open. Leonora was on the couch with one leg across Seth’s lap. His hand was under her blouse. When he saw me, he pulled it free and frowned. “You don’t know how to knock?” I’d lived there long enough to know which floorboard creaked on the way to the kitchen. He was asking me to knock. Leonora scrambled up, doing up her blouse with shaking fingers. Then she saw my face. “Clara. Who hit you?” My cheek had burned since I caught it on the chair at the clinic. I hadn’t looked in a mirror. From the way she stared, I figured it had started to bruise. “Tell me who did it,” she said, coming toward me. “I’ll go down there myself and…” “Drop it, Leonora.” I shoved her. She caught her heel on the edge of the rug and went down. Seth was off the couch before she could get up. He took her elbow, pulled her to her feet, and stepped in front of her. “What the hell is wrong with you? She asked if you were hurt.” “Clara, please,” Leonora said from behind him. Her eyes were already filling. “Just tell me what happened. Whoever did this, I’ll make them pay.” I tossed my phone onto the couch beside her. It landed screen up. “Go on,” I said. “Read the name at the top.” She bent just far enough to see it. Her hands dropped to her sides. “I didn’t put it in that chat,” she said. “Clara, you know I’d never do that to you.” She came toward me crying, reaching for my arm the way she used to when I got quiet in a crowded room. I slapped her before she could touch me. “I told you things I couldn’t tell anybody else. I took you to those appointments and sat up with you afterward. I never once pushed you to tell me his name.” My voice cracked. “And all that time it was Seth. Now your name’s on the message that sent that video around again.” “She doesn’t owe you for every favor you ever did her,” Seth said. “And a screenshot could come from anywhere. You really think that proves something?” He looked at Leonora’s cheek and his jaw tightened. “She baked your birthday cake in a dorm kitchen with one working burner. Remember that? When you got sick, she practically carried you to student health. She spent nights going after people who talked about you online. And this is what she gets?” I remembered the cake. She’d brought it to my room in the pan because she couldn’t get it out without breaking it. I’d eaten the first piece with a spoon while she sat cross-legged on my bed. Seth saw me hesitate. “Anyway,” he said, “you handed them the condom yourself. I saw the video, Clara. You went along with it.” The room went so quiet I could hear the ice settling in his glass. At the precinct, I’d told Seth why I’d done that before I managed to tell the detective. He’d sat there with my coat across his knees and told me to take my time. Now he was using the hardest thing I’d ever said out loud to win an argument. My teeth started to chatter. I pressed my lips together, but I couldn’t make it stop. “Seth,” Leonora said. “How dare you?” She shoved past him and put her arms around me. “I’m defending you,” he said. “She hit you. Why are you taking her side?” “Clara, listen to me.” Leonora held on tighter. “You were scared. You were trying to survive. Those men did that to you. It was their fault.” I looked past her at my phone on the couch. The screen had gone dark. “Say something,” she whispered. When I didn’t, she caught Seth by the sleeve and pulled him closer. “She’ll listen to you. Please. Say something to her.” Seth got a good look at my face. His mouth opened. For a second, I thought he might actually say he was sorry. He reached for me. I slapped his hand away. “I don’t want to see either of you,” I said. “Get out.” Seth let his hand drop. The look on his face changed. “Take a look around, Clara. This is my apartment. If you want somebody to leave, it’ll be you.” My shoes were under the hall bench. A stack of wedding invitations sat on the console where I’d left them. The apartment belonged to Seth, and the doorman would take my key the second he asked. I knew how quickly a place could stop being home. The Hensons had taught me that. I started laughing. By the time I could speak, tears were running down my face. “Fine,” I said. “You’ll never have to ask me to knock again.” I picked up my phone and left the key on top of the invitations. Outside, I walked until the doormen stopped looking familiar. My thumb went to Leonora’s name out of habit. She was the person I would’ve called if Seth had put me out. If Leonora had hurt me, I would’ve called Seth. By Saturday, I was supposed to be in Harbor City, marrying into the Ashford family. Right then, I couldn’t think of one door in New York I wanted to knock on. I put my phone in my pocket and kept walking.

Chapter 4

“Clara! There she is!” I was several blocks from the apartment when I heard Leonora. A black Vance sedan idled at the curb behind me, its rear door open. She hurried toward me in heels, one hand holding her coat shut against the wind. “Clara, it’s starting to rain.” She caught my hand. “Come home with us, okay?” I pulled free. “That’s Seth’s home. He made that clear.” Seth came up behind her. “Can you stop making a scene?” There wasn’t anybody on the sidewalk except the three of us and his driver. I kept walking. A moment later my feet left the ground. Seth had hauled me over his shoulder. The sight of the pavement swinging beneath me scared me badly enough that for a second I couldn’t get a word out. Then I hit him between the shoulder blades with both fists. “Put me down, Seth!” “Get in the damn car. Leonora’s going to get sick standing out here in the rain because of you.” “I didn’t ask either of you to come after me!” I twisted until he lost his grip and set me down. I backed away before he could grab me again. “Are you finished?” he asked. “If Leonora hadn’t insisted we come looking for you, I’d have left you alone.” “I should thank her, then. I only just got away from the man at the clinic who saw that video.” “She told you she didn’t send it. For Christ’s sake, Clara, why do you have to be so unreasonable?” I’d gone to work to hand in a resignation letter. I’d left on shaking legs with my keys still under a chair. I could tell him every detail, and he’d still find a way to make this about Leonora standing in the rain. “Sure,” I said. “I’m the unreasonable one.” I turned toward the avenue. At the corner, I stepped off the curb just as a car came around the bend. “Clara, watch out!” They shouted at the same time. Leonora caught my sleeve and tried to pull me back. The headlights swung across her face, and then the car hit us both. I remember landing. I remember trying to take a breath and getting almost nothing. Leonora was somewhere to my left. I could hear her trying to breathe, too. “Leonora!” Seth ran past me so close I saw the wet cuff of his trousers. He dropped to his knees beside her and kept saying her name. That was the last thing I heard. Four days passed before I was awake enough to know where I was. The blinds were half closed. Beyond them, I could make out the hospital’s brick wing and a strip of gray sky. A man in a dark suit stood on the other side of the door with his hands folded in front of him. I recognized him from the Marlowe. “Clara.” Seth pushed himself up from the chair. “You’re finally awake.” I looked at him and saw his shoes going past me on the pavement. I tried to smile. The effort hurt my face. He reached over to brush my hair back. “If I’d known you were going to take it this hard, I would’ve kept it to myself.” I turned my head away from his hand. “I didn’t want to lie to you,” he said. “I thought you’d at least give me credit for that.” He waited. When I didn’t answer, he pulled his chair closer. “I know why it’s hard for you to be touched, Clara. I’ve always respected that. Can’t you respect that I have needs, too? Leonora takes care of that part. You’re the one I love.” He said it in the same patient voice he’d used at the precinct when I couldn’t finish a sentence. “You’re revolting,” I said. He sat back. For a moment he looked genuinely hurt. Then his eyes went to the clock on the wall. “Okay. I’m sorry. This one’s on me. I won’t upset you again.” He leaned in and lowered his voice. “Come on, baby. Tell me you forgive me.” I put a hand against his chest and pushed him back. “Would it make any difference if I did?” “It matters to me,” he said at once. “Fine. I forgive you. Now get out.” He was on his feet before I finished speaking. He left the room without asking if I needed anything. A nurse came in to check on me. I asked for my clothes and phone. She brought them from the cabinet and told me to take it slowly if I wanted to try walking. I sat on the side of the bed until the room stopped spinning, then made it out to the hall. I wanted to call Mrs. Henson and find out what had happened while I was out. I’d gone three doors down when I heard Seth. “Leonora, you said I could stay once Clara forgave me. She did. I’ll take the chair by the window if that makes you feel better.” I stopped with my fingertips against the wall. The door was open a few inches. I could see the foot of a hospital bed and Seth’s jacket hanging on the back of a chair. “What about the wedding?” Leonora asked. Her voice was faint. “It’s the day after tomorrow. Can’t you call it off?” “No. I gave Clara my word. I’m going to marry her. But you and I can still see each other afterward. I promise.” I made it to the bathroom across the hall, shut the door, and was on my knees before I could lock it. When I came out, four men in dark coats were waiting in the corridor. The Vance guard stood outside my room, watching them. The oldest of the four stepped forward. Mrs. Henson had shown me a photograph of him when she first proposed the exchange. He was Mrs. Ashford’s right hand. “Ms. Henson, the Ashfords have moved up the ceremony. Mrs. Ashford sent a medical transport team. If you still want to come to Harbor City, the doctors need to arrange your transfer.”

More NovelShort Novels